|
hnt6581 CC
Do you feel safe at home? This is one of the questions the emergency room nurse asks me as I lie on a table, my left knee resting on a large ice pack. Many doctors started asking it in the 2010s, following a recommendation from the Institute of Medicine. Then, in 2013, the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force issued a stronger recommendation: all health care clinicians should ask it as a method of screening for domestic abuse. It’s like when doctors ask their patients, How many drinks a week do you have? hoping the answer will help them detect a drinking problem. I understand the usefulness of both questions. Still, I’m not convinced either one is the best way to find out what’s really going on. But the question I was asked, Do you feel safe at home? which, by the way, I answered yes, made me wonder about the other ways I could have responded. I could have said, “Well, I live by myself, so yes, I feel safe at home. Do you want to ask a more direct follow-up question?” But I wouldn’t actually say that. Even with my knee throbbing, I knew it would be rude, and anyhow, I thought the nurse was very kind. She told me about her friend who hurt her knee three days before the Boston Marathon and couldn’t run it. Still, the question lingered. All week, I kept having an imaginary conversation. If I knew I wouldn’t be judged, or that the ER nurse wouldn’t call for a psych evaluation, I might have said, “No, I don’t always feel safe at home because sometimes my thoughts haunt me.” Then I’d rush to head her off: “I don’t think of killing myself. That’s not the kind of unsafe I mean.” I don’t look at knives and think, I want to slit my wrists. When I look at my knives, I’m usually thinking about taking them to the hardware store to get sharpened because they’re so dull. And then I get down on myself because I know I’ve been putting it off for well over a year. I’d hope that answer would ease any concern the ER nurse had about me being suicidal. I’d also hope my self-deprecating humor might earn at least a small chuckle. The question, Are you safe at home? asks for something brief, reassuring. Sometimes the questioner is not even looking up from the computer when asking. I answered yes. The nurse nodded. Question asked and answered. So tidy. Then the nurse moved on. My chart was complete. My answer, not so much. Rachel Newcombe is a psychoanalyst on Orcas Island, WA. She co-leads a writing collective of fellow therapists who share an interest in writing from the margins and exploring ways creative non-fiction, poetry and art can be an aspect of professional writing. As a teacher she practices a radical pedagogy and thrives in a room of the disobedient who refuse indoctrination. She learns with and from students who dare to question and make learning their own. She can be found on Twitter @rachelnewcombe8 where she enjoys writing daily micro-fiction with the group #vss365.
1 Comment
Barbara Hancock
5/18/2026 12:11:37 pm
Love this Rachel! The “what ifs” hit at various times. Especially at night going to bed.
Reply
Your comment will be posted after it is approved.
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. Archives
November 2026
Categories |
RSS Feed